Colin.Guthr.ie Illegitimi non carborundum

PulseAudio Phonon Support now in KDE trunk and heading towards 4.4

I've very pleased to announce that my work on Phonon to integrate support for PulseAudio has now been committed to trunk and will form part of KDE 4.4 \o/

There were a few teething problems due to some last minute merges I did (which I clearly didn't test properly - my bad) and which I then went on to mis-interpret which led me to commit two rather silly things in phonon (a revert and then a revert of that revert!). What can I say... I need more caffeine obviously!

Update on KDE+PulseAudio

Just a small note to update on the progress.

The Test button now selects the right device. The way of achieving this is a little convoluted, but it seems to work well. We now generate a UUID for every phonon stream and push this into the PulseAudio stream proplist via an environment variable. We then look for all the streams in pulse and match up our UUID such that we can match up the pulse stream index to our phonon stream. We can then use this to move the stream to the appropriate device. Due to the async nature of PulseAudio, phonon sometimes requests the move before the stream is actually setup, so we have to queue up the move requests and process them when a stream appears. This approach also has the effect of causing the specific sink to be saved in module-stream-restore database, but this shouldn't matter in practice as phonon will always move it, so if the priority list changes, then we will always set the right device one way or the other even if the whole rigmarole could be avoided. But like I say, the practical outcome is fine, so let's just leave that for now.

The category is also passed through to PulseAudio now, so the the only thing that is not handled is when PulseAudio disconnects/restarts. Thankfully this is now getting less and less often as stability improves

KDE + PulseAudio != Sucks

So I've been spending altogether far too much time on getting this stuff working, but it's finally in a state where it no longer sucks.

For several releases we (Mandriva) have been patching KDE's phonon support to hide all the real devices if PulseAudio is used because the GUI really makes no sense (PulseAudio handles all the routing for us). This is an acceptable solution but it's far from ideal.

So with the latest set of three patches (one for pulseaudio, one for phonon and the final one for kdebase4-runtime) I now have a fully working system (albeit with some caveats!).